Example #3: Ragan Phillips

Dear Ed,

I am writing to you, and including the attached document, out of my genuine concern for the Hanover County Public Schools.

Stated in its simplest form my argument would be that the best investment we can  make in Hanover County is in our school system. Over the past ten years the County has slowly starved the school system of funding.

The attached document has been submitted for publication to the Herald-Progress. My intent is to assure that all residents of Ashland and the county have the opportunity to read these words and consider the facts.

I am a Republican and a staunch fiscal conservative. But I believe we, as Hanover County, have gone too far in “disinvesting” in our schools. The County is now at a crossroads when it comes to the quality of our schools. The BOS can provide leadership and turn this around…or they can allow the situation to continue to deteriorate.

I implore you to give this critical matter thoughtful, reasoned consideration.


Ragan Phillips

Ashland, Virginia

Copy of the Letter to the Editor, submitted by Ragan Phillips:




Any time we write a check or spend cash we expect to receive something of value in return. In business and banking circles this is referred to as the “return- on- investment.”

Strong businesses and organizations tend to make investments in their core strengths. And, consequently, receive a good return-on-investment.

Hanover County has a number of core strengths that make it an outstanding place to live. County residents enjoy having green space around them, e.g., drive outside any community in the county and you are in farmland. Another strength of Hanover would be the school system throughout the county. School quality is always a very important factor for people who are relocating their families or deciding to open a new business.

An outstanding school system will have an excellent ROI for its community. New residents will be attracted to the area. They will bring new skill sets, new businesses, disposal income, and additional tax revenue. Both new and old businesses will flourish. Property values will increase because people will want to live where there are the best schools…along with the trees and green fields.

In an area with a strong education system its graduates will know they have opportunities to work because of that education. A great education will provide our graduates opportunity in today’s challenging, rapidly changing, high technology and very competitive world. The subtle return on our education investment will, over time, correlate with less social flaws, i.e.,   crime, high unemployment, single parent homes, lack of civility and other anti-social behavior.

If we, as a society, want to do better in the future a strong, forward-thinking educational system is a must.

In My Opinion…the very best financial investment the residents of Hanover County can make is in the Hanover County School System. I am not suggesting that we just maintain the status quo. We have had a very fine system…but with a sound, continuing investment it could be much better. It could be a great education system.

I believe the School Board, at the behest of the Board of Supervisors, is asking the wrong question of Superintendent Jamelle Wilson and the school financial personnel. The question being put forth is, “How are you going to reduce costs to make up for the lost revenue?” But the right question is, “What do you need to make the Hanover County School System the best in the Commonwealth of Virginia?”

Suppose Dr. Wilson and her staff answered the “right” question and a determination of priority was made as to where any new funding would be used. What would the residents of Hanover say if asked to pay higher taxes, with the additional revenue going 100% to the schools system? No doubt there would be dissenters.  But I believe that a large majority of citizens would see the wisdom of investing in and strengthening our school system.

But the solution will not be easy. We have been “disinvesting’ in our Hanover school system for the past ten years. In 2003 education represented 67% of the County’s funding. Over the next ten years the County’s tax revenue increased by 44%. In 2012 education received 47% of the County’s funding. During this ten years student enrollment has declined by only three percent (3%) while federal and state mandates (primarily paperwork) have meant an increased workload on teachers.

In inflation adjusted dollars the County has decreased education funding by 25% over the past ten years. Over the past five years the revenues for school funding have decreased by $35 million, a decrease of some 17%.

But the impact is not dramatic, not like stepping into the yard and suddenly being faced by a ten foot King cobra. Our funding leakage over the past ten years is more like a very dangerous snake in the grass, one that slithers along unnoticed until it strikes. As residents we may have some occasional worry about the schools in Hanover County but pretty soon our attention is directed elsewhere. There has been no “Patrick Henry moment “to get us up in arms.

Over the past few years we have continued to ask our teachers to do more with less. Support staff has been reduced. Class sizes continue to increase…now projected to be a 22:1 pupil to teacher ratio. A teacher simply cannot give everyone in that class the personal attention that is one of the hallmarks of a great education system. And if that teacher has one or two “difficult” students then all bets are off. Textbooks are dated 2002. Technology resources are limited. The 2013-14 budget calls for $300,000 in technology for a schools system using 2003 software.

An aside:  Following Supervisor Peterson’s public meeting over in Mechanicsville on January 15 a gentleman (he proudly proclaimed to be a member of the Committee of Eleven that recommended elimination of the County’s proffer system) told me that teachers in Hanover schools only work four and one-half hours a day. So, by his logic, which I rather heatedly disputed, if we demand our teachers work, say, eight hours a day then all of our problems will be settled. If you buy that story I also have an East River bridge up in New York City that I can sell to you for a very reasonable price.

Unfortunately the county has, according to the staff report to the BOS on November 28, 2012, through the elimination of proffers removed $100 million or so from county revenue over the next decade.  Some 40%, about $40 million, of this amount would have been directed to the capital improvements of the school system. This deficiency will likely be funded through further reductions in operating costs (read this as the elimination of teachers) resulting in a further and continuing “disinvestment” in our schools.

School funding will continue to be curtailed unless concerned citizens make their case in the public forum. If we are concerned about education we can respond by going to School Board and Supervisor meetings, by writing to officials about your concerns…by being heard!

Or, if you agree teachers only work four and one-half hours a day, if education of our children is unimportant to you, you can rest easy in front of your TV.

I conclude with sage advice from John Wooden: “Failure to prepare is preparing to fail.”

You decide. It is one of our freedoms.

Ragan Phillips



One thought on “Example #3: Ragan Phillips

  1. Well stated. I couldn’t agree with you more. Going back to colonial times, each generation has passed forward onto the next an education system and an opportunity to get a better education than the previous generation had. I can give up nearly anything else in our community except this expectation that our schools will be invested in so that they keep up with the changing times.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s